Actors Who Refused Roles In Ben Stiller Movies

Over the span of the last 30 years or so, Ben Stiller has become one of the most powerful people in Hollywood as a bankable name associated with TV shows and movies that earn critical acclaim, commercial success, or both. He's multi-faceted, too, evolving from a maker of short comic films to star of his own sketch comedy series to A-list comic actor, headlining classic, crowd-pleasing movies like "There's Something About Mary," "Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story," "Zoolander," and three blockbuster "Meet the Parents" movies. Stiller is also a cameo machine, popping up in his friends' and collaborators' movies all the time, even as he's scaled back on major acting work to focus on writing and directing movies and TV shows, from both comic and dramatic projects — notably, he created "Severance," one of 2022's most acclaimed shows.

Stiller is such a force for highly visible and high quality entertainment that it seems foolish or ill-advised for an actor of any level to turn down the chance to appear in a movie starring or made by the actor. And yet, they have their reasons for those casting near-misses. Here are all the times that actors could've taken on a big part in a Ben Stiller movie but passed instead.

Although it lasted just one season and aired to dismal ratings — it was the least-watched show of the 1992-93 TV season — "The Ben Stiller Show" proved highly influential in that it created lasting creative partnerships among its four main cast members. In the years after the sketch show's cancellation, Ben Stiller frequently cast his costars in his directorial projects — Janeane Garofalo starred in "Reality Bites" and Bob Odenkirk appeared in "The Cable Guy," for example. And when Stiller co-wrote and ultimately directed the geopolitical-meets-male-modeling farce "Zoolander," he did so with "The Ben Stiller Show" alumnus Andy Dick in mind. "Andy Dick was supposed to play Mugatu," Stiller told Esquire, referring to the film's villain, a campy and extremely ridiculous fashion industry stalwart who hatches a scheme to brainwash models into killing the prime minister of Malaysia, who wants to end the sweatshop labor on which Mugatu's industry relies. "Now it's impossible for me to picture anybody but Will doing it," Stiller added — obviously, Will Ferrell played the memorable part in the 2001 film in one of his first major movie roles since becoming a star on "Saturday Night Live." 

So what's the reason Dick had to pass on a role written and earmarked for him? Well, he was busy. At the time that "Zoolander" entered production, Dick was committed to the short-lived NBC sitcom "Go Fish," which was then canceled after five episodes. However, Dick did appear in "Zoolander" — albeit in a much smaller role as the masseuse Olga.

There are a lot of big-name actors in the 2011 heist comedy "Tower Heist," the story of a bunch of wronged workers learn that their boss has swindled them out of their money via a Ponzi scheme who then decide to rob his luxury condo in a fancy New York skyscraper. The movie features an all-star cast including Ben Stiller, Eddie Murphy, Casey Affleck, Matthew Broderick, Gabourey Sidibe, Judd Hirsch, and Michael Peña, but it does not feature all-time cinematic superstar Robert Redford, an A-lister from the 1960s well into the '90s who took a long break from acting in the mid-2000s. After his 2007 drama "Lions for Lambs," Redford didn't appear in another film for five years, focusing on directing "The Conspirator" and "The Company You Keep."

"Tower Heist" was produced and released during that hiatus, and director Brett Ratner approached Redford about playing the role of evil boss and robbery target Arthur Shaw. But he passed. "I think he was finishing his movie or whatever, I don't know exactly what happened," Ratner told Collider. Alan Alda got the part instead.

Indie filmmaker Noah Baumbach frequently grapples with modern relationships, and in his 2014 dramedy "While We're Young," he explores what happens to a solid and content marriage between two middle-aged people when they meet a cool, hip young couple that make them feel old and stodgy. It took nearly four years for the film to get made, with IndieWire reporting casting news in 2010, that Stiller was set to star as the male half of the older couple, married to a character played by Greta Gerwig,  according to The Hollywood Reporter. Gerwig is a frequent collaborator of Baumbauch, as well as his romantic partner, so this casting made perfect sense in the moment.

Pairing Stiller and Gerwig together would've represented a re-teaming of the leads from Baumbach's 2010 movie "Greenberg," but it wouldn't come to pass. Gerwig left the film over scheduling issues, leaving the role to Cate Blanchett... but that wasn't the end of the casting changes for this movie. When the film debuted in theaters in 2014, it was Naomi Watts who played Stiller's on-screen spouse.

The "Madagascar" films have proven to be a popular and lucrative franchise for DreamWorks Animation, with the three flagship films and the "Penguins of Madagascar" spinoff raking in more than $2.2 billion at the global box office. They're star-driven, too, with a cast headed up by the recognizable voices of David Schwimmer, Chris Rock, and Ben Stiller, who plays a lion named Alex.

Stiller got his big acting break in 1989 when he joined the cast of "Saturday Night Live," but he left after three episodes, at a time in which Dana Carvey dominated the sketch show. Carvey nearly had a leading role in "Madagascar," too, which would have represented a big part of a comeback attempt. In the late 1990s, Carvey took an extended break from Hollywood to raise his two young children and to convalesce from a series of heart surgeries, according to People. In that time, he passed on two voice acting roles in what would be two of the most notable animated features of the mid-2000s: "Ratatouille," and "Madagascar." As Carvey told People, "I was very, very busy raising kids at that time."

By the late 1990s, Ben Stiller was known almost exclusively as a comic actor, what with his acclaimed sketch comedy series "The Ben Stiller Show," and roles in "Reality Bites," "Happy Gilmore," and "The Cable Guy." In 1998, he branched out into much darker and much more dramatic fare with "Permanent Midnight," which tells the true story of Jerry Stahl, a TV sitcom writer (best known for "ALF," "Moonlighting," and "thirtysomething") who grappled with an addiction to heroin.

According to Entertainment Weekly, Stiller prepared extensively and seriously for his dramatic turn, hanging out with Stahl and losing 30 pounds to more effectively get into character. Still, Stiller wasn't producers' first choice for the part. Another up and coming actor of the era looking to prove that he could do more than just the one thing for which he was known previously landed the lead in "Permanent Midnight." David Duchovny, attempting to forge a movie career outside of the hit TV show "The X-Files," signed on to portray Stahl, but pulled out in order to make the flop "Playing God" instead.

Ben Stiller's "Zoolander" is a silly movie, but its 2016 sequel, "Zoolander 2" is even sillier. Extraordinarily stupid male models Derek Zoolander (Stiller) and Hansel (Owen Wilson) reunite in Rome and find themselves embroiled in another deadly international conspiracy which they somehow solve and survive — in spite of their staggering lack of intelligence. The standout scenes in the movie, however, involve Hansel's personal life, in which he's in a polyamorous relationship with a relative horde of people, both men and women... all of whom he manages to impregnate. That arrangement is depicted in a wildly over-the-top, heavily populated group-love scene played for laughs, and in his capacity as "Zoolander 2" director, Stiller tried and failed to a very famous and very unlikely face in the mix.

"I was going to ask her to be a member of that group," Stiller told NBC's "Today" (via the Washington Post) regarding former First Lady of the United States, Laura Bush. He didn't provide Bush or her reps with the details of the part, but she declined anyway. "She was so smart to politely say no," Stiller said. The "Zoolander" movies send-up the world of high fashion, and Stiller sought out a real-life representative of that subculture, asking designer and Chanel creative chief Karl Lagerfeld to participate. According to Hello!, that was absolutely out of the question for Lagerfeld.