The One Thing These Actors Would Change About Their Most Iconic Characters

Some actors will forever be associated with one character, even if they have a varied body of work behind them. For example, Jim Parsons will forever be known as Sheldon Cooper, Jennifer Aniston is never going to stop being Rachel from "Friends," and Michael J. Fox will always be remembered as Marty McFly. 

However, other actors are less accepting of their beloved roles in their entirety and, while they are generally very proud of them, they may have one major regret or something they would change about their character. Many have been vocal about the one thing they're not totally happy with, whether it's from a pretty recent (but now iconic) role that doesn't sit right with an actor, or something that a star has been stewing on for decades. Let's dive into the one thing these actors would change about their most iconic characters, exploring roles in several popular franchises from "Star Trek" to "Star Wars" to "Game of Thrones."

Kerr Smith has played some memorable roles throughout his career, including Ryan Thomas in "Life Unexpected," Kyle Brody in "Charmed," and Principal Holden Honey in "Riverdale." But none of his characters are more iconic than Jack McPhee from "Dawson's Creek."

Smith created a lasting legacy for Jack, as one-half of the first gay kiss on Primetime. He shared this moment with Adam Kaufman, who played Ethan Brody, Jack's prom date. "I did know how historic it was and he did too ... we knew that it was important and that a lot of people were going to be looking up to the show now for this particular type of storyline," he told Los Angeles Times. "I think we did a good thing. I think that storyline probably helped a lot of people in real life." The kiss was historic and led to other relationships for Jack.

One of those relationships is with Pacey Witter's (Joshua Jackson) older brother, Doug (Dylan Neal). In fact, this is Jack's endgame romance and the pair ultimately ends up adopting Jen Lindley's (Michelle Williams) daughter, Amy. However, Smith takes issue with Jack's last beau, admitting that their relationship is the one thing he'd change for his character. "I gotta be honest. I thought that was a little cheat. It was funny, yeah, that they made Doug, Pacey's older brother the cop, gay and got him and Jack together in the end. I don't know. I thought that was a little cheat," Smith said.

Lauren Graham has successfully forged a career for herself as a TV mom. The Week observed, "Graham's career has almost single-handedly elevated the single mother — that sad sack, that cautionary tale — to a protagonist worth investing in dramatically, with humor and interest and a full, complicated arc." And it all started with her "Gilmore Girls" character, Lorelai Gilmore, the plucky single mom to Rory (Alexis Bledel).

After playing the fast-talking coffee addict for seven seasons of TV and four reunion movies, Graham told People that no role will ever suit her better than the Stars Hollow local. However, she has since admitted that there's one thing about her beloved character that she would change if she could: Lorelai wouldn't marry Christopher (David Sutcliffe) in Season 7. "I have to admit, this seemed so odd to me back then (especially after all that time apart; I just don't think Lorelai would get married without Rory present)," she wrote in her first memoir, "Talking As Fast As I Can" (via Entertainment Weekly).

And of course, true fans know she's right. Lorelai and Rory do everything together — from Rory's first date with Dean to her first night at Yale. They are there for all of each other's important milestones, so marrying Chris is just too out of character for Lorelai. It's no wonder Graham forgot it even happened. She knows what fans knew all along: Lorelai and Luke belong together.

Robert Pattinson's creative battle over portraying Edward Cullen in the "Twilight" franchise is well documented in that he initially wanted the character to be darker and more emo. "I was 21, and I kind of wanted to make it as arty as possible ... I thought that was the only way to play it," he explained to GQ. However, the studio wasn't keen on his vision, and ultimately his agent told him if he didn't smile more, he was going to get fired. Eventually, Pattinson compromised, not wanting to lose his job.

Now, with time and distance, he has positive memories of making the movies, despite some of his past comments. After all, the franchise launched his career and led to him taking on the iconic role of Bruce Wayne in Matt Reeves' 2022 film, "The Batman." But, when Pattinson looks back on his time as Edward, there's one thing about the character he would still change: Edward should have behaved more like a stereotypical vampire. "I hardly get to do any vampire stuff. I don't get to kill anyone," he said in a behind-the-scenes video promoting "New Moon" (via Screen Rant).

Edward does eventually get to do more "vampire stuff" when he kills Victoria, literally snapping her head clean off her body in "Eclipse." But, Pattinson's complaint is valid since he didn't get to play on traditional vampire tropes like drinking human blood, especially in the first film.

Ellen Pompeo has played the titular "Grey's Anatomy" character, Meredith Grey, all the way from being a wide-eyed young intern to taking over from Miranda Bailey (Chandra Wilson) as Grey Sloan's chief of surgery. But, in a shocking twist, Pompeo exited the show midway through Season 19. She later admitted that the reason she stayed on the show for so long was that she made the decision to make money, rather than pursue other creative opportunities. That's not to say she doesn't love her character, though, but there is one thing about Meredith that Pompeo admits she would change if she could: Meredith wouldn't have a new love interest straight after Derek's (Patrick Dempsey) death.

It was always obvious to Pompeo (and fans) that after Derek died, Meredith should have been able to take some time for herself, grieve, and focus on her family, and even her career. Martin Henderson was brought in to play Nathan Riggs, but viewers were unimpressed and he ultimately left the series. Looking back on the decision, she told The Hollywood Reporter, "I was like, 'Are you people f***king nuts? Why do you feel that you have to replace [Derek]?' I couldn't believe how fast the studio and the network felt like they had to get a penis in there."

Afterward, Meredith goes on to have a couple more significant relationships, including with Andrew DeLuca (Giacomo Gianniotti) and Nick Marsh (Scott Speedman). Although her exit from the series, which saw her leave without Nick, proved Pompeo's point; Meredith doesn't always need a man around.

Mark Hamill has been plenty vocal about his role as Luke Skywalker in the original and sequel trilogies. Briefly returning to the franchise in "The Force Awakens," he took on a bigger role in "The Last Jedi," but spoke out about his clash with director Rian Johnson over their respective visions for Luke. "I said to Rian, 'Jedis don't give up.' I mean, even if [Luke] had a problem, he would maybe take a year to try and regroup, but if he made a mistake, he would try and right that wrong, so right there, we had a fundamental difference," he explained (via Collider).

Luke's determination is something Hamill has understood about his character since the original franchise. He proves this when he blows up the Death Star, and he had hoped that his iconic character was going to get the chance to demonstrate this again in "Return of the Jedi" by briefly going over to the dark side and finding his way back. "Because I was wearing all black. I thought I would go to the dark side in the last one. And, of course, you have to redeem yourself. But that movie is the way I felt it was going with the preceding episode. But every actor wants to play their own evil twin," he told Entertainment Weekly. Hamill added that the direction George Lucas did take the character was definitely the way to go, but, at the time, he wanted to make a pretty major change to his character's arc.

Despite being one of the earlier roles in Kate Winslet's career, the British star's name is still synonymous with her "Titanic" character, Rose. As a result of the 1997 movie, she's formed an unbreakable friendship with her co-star, Leonardo DiCaprio. The award-winning feature has endured over the decades, praised for its timeless romance, but also criticized for its heartbreaking ending. Winslet has since weighed in on that ending, telling ET that if she could change one thing about it, she would have Rose make room for Jack on the door: "I think he probably could have gotten on the door. I mean, you know, I live with this."

After Jack and Rose have escaped the sinking ship, Jack famously can't fit on the door which he helps Rose onto and freezes to death in the ice cold water. In theory, he sacrifices himself in order to save her, but according to Winslet, this needn't have been necessary. She discussed this again on "The Graham Norton Show," which shared a behind-the-scenes clip of herself, DiCaprio, and director James Cameron, all being easily held up by the door, proving that it could have been possible.

Winslet has been back and forth on this topic for over 25 years and while she's appeared conflicted about the science of them both surviving on the door, it's clear Winslet thinks Rose should have at least tried to make room for him.

Oscar Isaac is proof that good things come to those who wait — and work hard. Although he had appeared in "Ex Machina" and "X-Men: Apocalypse," it wasn't until he landed the role of Poe Dameron in "The Force Awakens" that Isaac got his international breakout role. Since then, Isaac joined the cast of another successful franchise, playing multiple characters in Marvel's superhero series "Moon Knight." The Guatemalan-born actor owes a lot to the "Star Wars" sequel trilogy and is thrilled to have been a part of it. However, there is one thing he would change about it if he could: Isaac thinks Poe should have had a romantic moment with John Boyega's Finn.

"There was an absolute natural chemistry with him ... there's like an intimacy that was very just, like, there," Isaac explained to Variety. This was evident to fans, who were rooting for the two to get together. "It wasn't actually a total shock [that] people, you know, saw that in there. Personally, I kind of hoped and wished that maybe that would have been taken further in the other films, but I don't have control over that," Isaac added.

Sadly, Disney didn't seem to get the memo that Poe and Finn were really endgame and instead paired them up with other love interests. Finn has a flirtation with Rose Tico (Kelly Marie Tran) that's never fully fleshed out, while Poe's attraction to Zorii Bliss (Keri Russell) is not reciprocated.